Skip to Main Content
Bringing Catholic Values to Life
Click to open Main Navigation

Make a Payment

Catholic Order of Foresters offers three convenient ways to make a payment!

  1. Online single payment option: Payment is handled through a secure login process that allows you to pay your bill day or night using your credit or debit card or personal checking or savings account. The payment will be processed through Simply Easier Payments, our partner, who accepts:
    • Credit or Debit Card
      Pay your bill by having the total amount of your bill charged to your credit or debit card. All major credit cards including Visa, Mastercard, Discover, and American Express are accepted. Simply Easier Payment charges a fee to pay with credit or with debit card.
    • E-check
      Pay your bill by having the total amount of your bill deducted from your checking or savings account. There is no fee for paying via e-check.

    To complete your online payment, you will need:
    • The policy and BCN numbers listed on your billing statement
      (View Sample 1 or View Sample 2)
    • The five-digit zip/postal code shown on the billing statement
    • Your bank routing and account numbers (for payment via E-check only) (View Sample)

    What payments are accepted online?
    Premium renewal payments and annuity contributions are accepted, although we do NOT recommend paying annuity contributions with a credit card.

    Advance payments and reinstatements are NOT accepted through Simply Easier Payments.

    Ready to make your online payment? Click the “Pay Now” button below!

    Make Payment using SEP

    Is online bill pay secure?
    Simply Easier Payments will manage your payment with PCI DSS Level 1 validation, the highest level of security. In addition, this system includes a secure Payment Information Storage Vault, which safely stores your payment information offsite. As a result, your data and funds will always be protected.

  2. Recurring payment option: Pay your bill automatically by having your premium deducted monthly or annually from your checking or savings account. If you are interested in paying your premium by Preauthorized Automatic Check (PAC) Plan, complete this form and mail it to:

    Catholic Order of Foresters
    Attn: Member Services
    355 Shuman Boulevard
    Naperville, IL 60563-1270

  3. By mail payment option: Make your check payable to Catholic Order of Foresters and mail it along with your billing stub to:

    COF Lockbox
    PO Box 74791
    Chicago, IL 60694-4791

  4. Questions? Contact the Home Office at 800-552-0145 Monday through Friday, 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. CT.

    Facebook: 21-06-037A | Twitter: 21-06-037C | LinkedIn: 21-06-037B | Project Number: 21-07-009

Get Involved Faith, Hope, Charity, Feeding God's Children